Saturday, May 12, 2012

Keeping livestock for a more sustainable food system



Have you ever traveled through the farm fields of the Midwest and wondered why there is nothing but corn and soybeans as far as the eye can see? I'm sure it's not a question many Americans ask themselves because, by and large, we've lost our ability and our need to make connections between our food and the earth it comes from. All those fields of corn and soybeans are part of the huge portion of the United States that's devoted to producing the meat and dairy products that dominate our diet.

But not all Americans eat so much meat and dairy. Many vegans and vegetarians are opposed to the eating of animal products for environmental and/or animal rights reasons. From the perspective of the animal rights activist, animal production is inhumane, while to the environmentalist it is an inefficient use of land. Eating lower on the food chain is thought to have much less impact on the planet because, given the amount of plant matter required to feed animals, it would be more efficient to eat the plants ourselves.

It's easy to see how anyone could come up with many arguments as to why in the 21st century the industrial production of meat and other animal products could be considered cruel and unsustainable. It's estimated that livestock worldwide account for 20 percent of the total terrestrial animal biomass, a number that clearly illustrates our impact on life on the planet. Vast acreage is devoted to growing grain to feed livestock that are raised in inhumane conditions in factory farms and feedlots, all to provide a meat-based diet for those in affluent countries. As well, a UN report found that livestock are currently responsible for 18 percent of greenhouse gas emissions from human activity. Those consuming meat and animal products have little awareness of the lack of sustainability of and cruelty inherent to their food system.

Unfortunately, in arguments against animal agriculture often no distinction is made between the production of animals in factory farms and the more humane, small-scale keeping of livestock that has been the human norm for thousands of years. It is true that a vegetarian diet can require less land for a given population size, however, in terms of sustainability, there is evidence to support that making use of livestock in our food production system will be more sustainable over the long term. Livestock were raised sustainably for thousands of years before modern times, so it's obvious that livestock are not the problem; the number of them and the practices we use to raise them today are the problem. In the coming decades we will all have to find alternatives to fossil fuel if we are to survive. By doing away with livestock production we would be tossing out one of humanity's simplest and most valuable alternatives to fossil fuel and a vital means of lessening our impact on the planet.


Saturday, April 28, 2012

Swallows in Nigeria

Swallows that summer in Europe spend their winters far away in parts of Africa. Migratory birds like swallows are in the unfortunate and vulnerable position of being dependent on not just one isolated habitat, but on large swathes of the earth for their survival. Though their habitat in countries like Great Britain may be improving because of the efforts of conservationists, in other stretches of habitat along their migration routes they are under threat. Recently I was listening to the BBCs Natural History Radio and was struck by how the story of these swallows illustrates the disparity and unfairness in resource distribution among humans in the world today and how this inequality threatens natural systems.

First of all you have the British who, seeing declining populations of the swallows in their region, discovered the source of the decline to be in the winter home of the birds. In Nigeria, a country rich in oil and also the location of many migratory roosts for the birds on their long trip to South Africa, the majority of the population is so poor that these tiny birds have become a food source. An Italian team of ornithologists found that the swallows were being caught and sold as food by poor people in the region where the birds have returned to roost for thousands of years. As many as 200,000 swallows are being captured and killed each year in one small area of Nigeria. This episode of Natural History Radio focused on the success story, how conservationists were able to stop local people from catching and selling the swallows.

The solution was ecotourism. When swallow enthusiasts traveled from the rich world to see and study the roosts of the swallows in Nigeria each would have to pay a tax, the proceeds of which would go to the local population. This would give the locals a reason to allow the birds to live, because the swallows would be more valuable to them alive than dead.

Wednesday, February 22, 2012

Learning from Nature

Humans have been able to create technology that would seem to our predecessors like magic. Yet when we look at the web a spider weaves, we might not grasp the full wonder of what this little creature is accomplishing. The forces of nature drive living things toward maximum efficiency. Nature fills niches by evolving technologies that optimize use of the energy provided by the sun or the earth. The spider for instance, is able to spin many different kinds of webs for different applications that are stronger than steel. The spider can assemble its super strong fibers from the simple ingredients in its food using a tiny fraction of the energy it would take to create a fiber from petroleum-derived plastic, and the material is completely biodegradable.  On the other hand, thanks to the abundance of fossil fuel, we humans of the modern industrial world develop technologies that are incredibly wasteful and will be with us for thousands of years. We have a lot to learn from nature about reducing waste, and about conserving and storing energy.

In Our Time from BBC radio did this great show about Macromolecules that talks to experts about the potential for using polymers based on those found in nature for creating more sustainable products. Usually the show is an eclectic mix of topics across many disciplines, but this episode seems to touch on many topics relevant to making our lives more sustainable. This is a fun little listen that teaches us that if we look to nature for guidance, we can learn to reduce our impact on the planet.








Tuesday, December 27, 2011

Do We Want More Humans or Less?


The number of humans on earth just passed the 7 billion mark. To mark the occasion, there was a Planet Money podcast about countries whose populations are declining.   Some of the countries experiencing declines in population are affluent, places like Japan and Germany, where every new baby is, in terms of resource consumption, equivalent to dozens of babies in poor countries. But the podcast was not about how great it is to see this decline in population. Oddly, in rich countries the lack of population growth is seen as a problem, and governments are actually giving many incentives to people to have more babies. It's a strange paradox that though the world cannot survive overrun with humans as it is, some countries feel they cannot survive without a continually growing population. The notion that rich countries need a continuously growing population is linked to the belief that we need a continuously growing economy. The problem with both of these concepts is that the earth can sustain neither.

I've often thought there was an integral connection between population growth and economic growth. Though I don't have a background in economics, my knowledge about environmental issues and my interest in the way they relate to other disciplines such as economics, have helped me understand this connection better. In this Planet Money podcast, they explain this connection that is obvious to many economists. Each new baby is not just another mouth to feed, it is another consumer, another worker. In an unsustainable capitalist economy like ours in the US, each new kid is an excuse to tap more resources from the planet. The extraction of more resources is required to grow the economy at such a rapid rate. So when populations slow, as is explained in this podcast, economies stagnate. There aren't as many people buying stuff, there aren't as many people to work the jobs that contribute to the wealth of the economy. As well, there are fewer taxpayers and less revenue to sustain government programs.


Thursday, November 3, 2011

An Intro to this Blog: Thinking Across Disciplines

This is a new blog where I plan to discuss my thoughts on a number of different subjects in many different disciplines.  Through my history as a political and lifestyle activist, I have found it useful to have a knowledge that crosses boundaries between disciplines.  In a world with so many people and in a society that is by necessity so complex, we are forced to specialize in disciplines or occupations.  This specialization leads to a narrowing of perspective and we become unable to understand the world as a whole.  This is not all bad, because I believe that with the increase in complexity of our world as individuals our understanding of it has greatly increased.   Many of us can understand how our world works on a larger scale of complexity than our ancestors could, we can learn how we are negatively impacting it, and we can change.  

However, the complexity of what we have created with our vast population is still far beyond what any individual can understand.  We may view the world as a complex organism made up of many different specialized beings, each contributing to the survival of the whole.  Bees as individuals each perform a role that contributes to the survival of the hive.  But beehives are akin to well-oiled machines (though the perfection acheived by nature far surpasses that of any human invention), whereas the complex society of humanity is like a body where the brain doesn't know what the foot is doing. Things could be different.  We could be more like a well-oiled machine, but in my mind we are more like a free for all of individuals grabbing at resources to meet our basic needs or simply to make our lives more entertaining. 

Often I will be listening to the theories of a specialist like say, I don't know, an economist, and it will be obvious to me that this expert doesn't know the slightest thing about disciplines that directly affect economics.  For instance, I don't know how any economist can possibly understand economic sustainability without understanding environmental sustainability.  The two are vitally linked.  Just one example is the common misunderstanding among economists that constant economic growth is possible in a world with finite resources.  This also illustrates a lack of understanding of the fundamental laws of physics.

I don't claim to be able to understand everything in every discipline, obviously, but I instead point out the necessity of looking at things on a larger level to understand certain ideas.   Instead of staying so isolated in our knowledge, we need to have a cross-disciplinary understanding of our world, to see how these complex systems interact.  In this blog I will try to write about complex ideas that I feel are very important in problem solving for a world confronting a major crisis, as I believe ours is right now.